What Gets Praised
Common Criticisms
This inspector awards Strong Standard when settings
demonstrate strategic barrier removal through hardship
funds, show comprehensive SEND support with all staff
trained in the graduated approach, and provide 'sustained
interactions' where staff draw on children's interests to
broaden understanding. She particularly values settings that
explain the 'why' behind expectations (behaviour, hygiene,
routines) so children develop understanding rather than just
compliance.
This inspector downgrades settings when key person
systems fail during transitions (leaving children without
named adults or consistent expectations), when staff give
instructions without explanations (e.g. 'be quiet' without
saying why), and when SEND strategies are not understood
by all staff. In Q3 2025 she issued statutory actions to a
setting requiring them to 'ensure that agreed strategies to
support children with SEND are fully understood and
implemented by all staff' and to 'put appropriate
arrangements in place for the supervision of staff, with
particular focus on their understanding of the curriculum'.
Strategic use of hardship funds to ensure disadvantaged
children can access trips, meals, and additional sessions
without financial barriers limiting participation (Q4 2025
Morris Green Out of School Club)
Key person system not consistently implemented during
transitions: 'some children are not allocated a named key
person in a timely manner, particularly when they move
rooms' leading to inconsistent behavioural expectations
and emotional support (Q4 2025 Brookdale Day Nursery)
Tailored adaptations for SEND children including 'sensory
regulation strategies, objects of reference, simplified
language and visual sequencing' that enable participation
alongside peers (Q4 2025 Portico)
Staff using closed questions or asking questions 'in quick
succession, not giving children time to think' which limits
language development opportunities (Q3 2025
childminder, Q3 2025 Yew Tree Pre-School)
Strong school partnerships with daily information sharing
so 'staff understand how children are feeling when they
arrive' and joint work on homework support/online safety
(Q4 2025 Morris Green Out of School Club)
Group activities too long or poorly differentiated: 'at times,
group sessions are too large and too long for some
younger children. Consequently, these children lose focus
and do not fully benefit from the intended learning' (Q3
2025 Mulberry Roots)
Physical development curriculum that combines large
muscle activities (outdoor climbing, sports) with targeted
small muscle work (mark making, tool use, dough
manipulation) to prepare for early writing (Q4 2025 Total
Tots, Q3 2025 Fernbank Nursery)
Hygiene routines enforced without explanation: 'children
are not consistently reminded to cover their mouths when
coughing to reduce the spread of germs' and staff don't
help children 'understand why good hygiene is important'
(Q3 2025 Mulberry Bush Nursery)
Communication and language teaching through 'sustained
interactions' where staff draw on children's interests (e.g.
helicopters/aeroplanes) to 'prompt meaningful discussion
about their own experiences' and 'broaden children's
understanding of the world' (Q4 2025 Total Tots)
Dummy overuse limiting communication: 'the use of
children's dummies to support emotional needs sometimes
overrides the opportunities they have to practise their
communication and language skills' (Q3 2025 Mulberry
Bush Nursery)
Transition support including 'experienced staff review each
child's progress and share the information needed with
children's new teachers to ensure a smooth move' with
particular attention to SEND children needing adjustments
(Q3 2025 Mulberry Bush Nursery)
Brief instructions without clear explanations: staff say 'be
quiet' which 'do not always help children understand why
they need to adjust their behaviour or what they should do
next' (Q4 2025 Morris Green Out of School Club)
Independence development through consistent routines
where children 'hang up their belongings on named pegs',
'confidently change their shoes', 'manage self-registration'
and 'seek out their own play choices' (Q3 2025 Yew Tree
Pre-School)
Inconsistent independence support: 'opportunities to build
children's independence within care routines, such as
encouraging children to attempt to put their coats on for
outdoor play, are not always maximised across rooms' (Q4
2025 Portico)
Cultural inclusivity where 'diverse staff team supports
children to understand similarities and differences as they
take part in celebrations such as Rosh Hashanah and
Diwali and learn about various faiths' (Q3 2025 Habonim
Nursery)
Curriculum implementation gaps: 'planned intent for some
activities is not always sharply focused on what individual
children need to learn next' with 'learning intentions are
Mealtimes as learning opportunities where children